The Broccoli Debate
Winning Entry by percypop
THE BROCCOLI DEBATE
The Council of Vegetables met in an emergency meeting in the Soup Kitchen.
The Grand Pumpkin asked for silence and glowered at a couple of radishes twittering on the back shelf.
"I have to announce" he said in his pompous pumpkin voice "that a desperate crisis has arisen in the Kitchen and action must be taken."
Whispering began among the lettuces who fluttered with anxiety.
"What's the problem Fatty?" The Mares Potato bellowed. He had tried to throw his weight about on earlier occasions but the rest of the bunch shouted him down.
Pumpkin ignored the interruption: "The Chef proposes to add Broccoli to the Cauliflower soup and call it Brocoflower Medley."
A wave of noise washed over the assembly. Peas and broad beans squeaked-avocados shrieked and a babble of runner beans wailed loudly.
"What desecration" said a superior Carrot "our Professional Standards will be in ruins. Imagine if he tried to make a carrot and onion cake or carrot and potato soup. The idea is appalling."
"Not so fast, you skinny red snob" said the Potato "I happen to know there is a thing called Potato and carrot soup sold in supermarkets."
The Carrot sniffed "I don't spend my time in Supermarkets." He turned away with a toss of his green shoots.
"Come to Order everyone " said Pumpkin "Shall we hear what Cauliflower wants to say about it?"
Cauliflower rose to his stalk;" Let me say I have nothing but the best regard for my green friend" here he nodded towards the Broccoli "But facts are facts and cauliflower soup is a perfect creamy colour accepted by the most discerning palates. There can be no green in it and the idea is" -- he hesitated before going on -- "PREPOSTEROUS"
The last word he shouted and three new potatoes fell over in alarm.
There was a silence for a moment and all eyes turned to Broccoli who sat wrapped in his broad leaves a few inches away.
At last he spoke "Who among you has won praise for his health giving minerals? Who can deny the plaudits showered on my fellow Broccoliers? The Press rave about the benefits of my steamed stalks. Only yesterday Nigella swore my Flowery heads were medicinal. So the value of this blend will be remarkable."
A rustle of agreement ran round the courgettes and cucumbers.
" Hang on" shouted the raw Potato " you've been planting yourself in all those North London Allotments-no wonder you get all these Trade endorsements!"
"But that is not the issue" said the Gran Pumpkin "We must decide whether we will boycott this idea or accept it."
"Ban It! Ban It!" chorused the cabbages and spring onions "We want no hybrids here."
"But you've already made a soup together" pointed out the Squash.
"What do we want? No new soups.-when do we want it?-Now"
chanted the cabbages and they drowned out the voices
of the petit pois who tried to speak.
"Let's have a vote of fronds" said Pumpkin and he counted up. The whole basket waved their appendages.
"Right" he said "no blend of Broccoli and Cauliflower it is"
The cooks arrived for work, read their instructions and began to prepare the vegetables for the soup of the day.
"Look at this Bob" said the sous chef "all the
cauliflower's gone mouldy."
"Bin it then "said Bob "get weaving on the broccoli."
"No luck there, it's shrivelled and stringy"
"Bloody Hell! We'll have to do carrot soups again."
They couldn't hear the giggles in the vegetable racks.
The Council of Vegetables met in an emergency meeting in the Soup Kitchen.
The Grand Pumpkin asked for silence and glowered at a couple of radishes twittering on the back shelf.
"I have to announce" he said in his pompous pumpkin voice "that a desperate crisis has arisen in the Kitchen and action must be taken."
Whispering began among the lettuces who fluttered with anxiety.
"What's the problem Fatty?" The Mares Potato bellowed. He had tried to throw his weight about on earlier occasions but the rest of the bunch shouted him down.
Pumpkin ignored the interruption: "The Chef proposes to add Broccoli to the Cauliflower soup and call it Brocoflower Medley."
A wave of noise washed over the assembly. Peas and broad beans squeaked-avocados shrieked and a babble of runner beans wailed loudly.
"What desecration" said a superior Carrot "our Professional Standards will be in ruins. Imagine if he tried to make a carrot and onion cake or carrot and potato soup. The idea is appalling."
"Not so fast, you skinny red snob" said the Potato "I happen to know there is a thing called Potato and carrot soup sold in supermarkets."
The Carrot sniffed "I don't spend my time in Supermarkets." He turned away with a toss of his green shoots.
"Come to Order everyone " said Pumpkin "Shall we hear what Cauliflower wants to say about it?"
Cauliflower rose to his stalk;" Let me say I have nothing but the best regard for my green friend" here he nodded towards the Broccoli "But facts are facts and cauliflower soup is a perfect creamy colour accepted by the most discerning palates. There can be no green in it and the idea is" -- he hesitated before going on -- "PREPOSTEROUS"
The last word he shouted and three new potatoes fell over in alarm.
There was a silence for a moment and all eyes turned to Broccoli who sat wrapped in his broad leaves a few inches away.
At last he spoke "Who among you has won praise for his health giving minerals? Who can deny the plaudits showered on my fellow Broccoliers? The Press rave about the benefits of my steamed stalks. Only yesterday Nigella swore my Flowery heads were medicinal. So the value of this blend will be remarkable."
A rustle of agreement ran round the courgettes and cucumbers.
" Hang on" shouted the raw Potato " you've been planting yourself in all those North London Allotments-no wonder you get all these Trade endorsements!"
"But that is not the issue" said the Gran Pumpkin "We must decide whether we will boycott this idea or accept it."
"Ban It! Ban It!" chorused the cabbages and spring onions "We want no hybrids here."
"But you've already made a soup together" pointed out the Squash.
"What do we want? No new soups.-when do we want it?-Now"
chanted the cabbages and they drowned out the voices
of the petit pois who tried to speak.
"Let's have a vote of fronds" said Pumpkin and he counted up. The whole basket waved their appendages.
"Right" he said "no blend of Broccoli and Cauliflower it is"
The cooks arrived for work, read their instructions and began to prepare the vegetables for the soup of the day.
"Look at this Bob" said the sous chef "all the
cauliflower's gone mouldy."
"Bin it then "said Bob "get weaving on the broccoli."
"No luck there, it's shrivelled and stringy"
"Bloody Hell! We'll have to do carrot soups again."
They couldn't hear the giggles in the vegetable racks.
Featured Entry by Phidgers
The chaos in the village of Ficti-on-Sea started at the autumn fair, in the Best Vegetable competition. And it began with broccoli. The judges gathered round the entries, looking important and making notes on checklists. This was their favourite time of year. People came from miles around to attend the fair. The competition was the jewel in the crown of the event, and winning it was prestigious indeed.
Adrian Henley, head of the judging panel and self proclaimed horticultural expert, cast an appraising eye over the offerings. His grey walrus moustache bristled with enthusiasm. A crowd always gathered to see what he made of things. The judging process was completely democratic. He and the six other members of the panel had an even say in the matter. The fact that his favourite entry had won every time in the contest’s twelve year history was mere coincidence. It had nothing to do with him being the head of the local police force. Rumours of Adrian holding delicate information over the heads of the other judges were just poor attempts by sour grapes to mar his reputation. Just because he did have access to such information proved nothing. He always picked the best entry anyway, so the argument was purely hypothetical.
Adrian smiled inwardly, whilst maintaining an air of outward professionalism. The crowd certainly was lively today. The contest marquee was full of people making their own inspections of the expertly grown vegetables. One entry in particular seemed to be drawing attention. He caught phrases such as ‘Never seen anything like it!’ and ‘I didn’t know you could do that with broccoli’. Adrian finished mentally destroying lot number five, a rather dismal pumpkin entered by Mrs Ashley. He headed to discover the source of the intrigue for himself. His career in the police force had made him hard to surprise. However, that assumption was about to be sorely tested.
Arriving at the entry in question, Adrian stopped short. His enthusiasm turned to confusion, and then to anger. This was clearly some sort of joke. It had to be. In front of him was a marrow. It was larger than average, but pretty unremarkable. At least it would have been, if not for the large heads of broccoli which sprouted from its top. Broccoli, which just happened to be a vibrant shade of purple. The ridiculous plants stuck up in a neat line, all along the marrow. If Adrian had been in a joking mood, he may have referred to it as the vegetable equivalent of a punk. He was not, however, in such a mood. The Best Vegetable competition was a prestigious and serious event. Stupid pranks had no place in it. He would get to the bottom of this, and the culprit would find themselves severely reprimanded.
‘Who is responsible for this… thing?’ he demanded. His heart sank, as someone stepped from the crowd and raised his hand. Professor Neil Morgan was a biologist, new to the area. He had moved to Ficti-on-Sea six months ago, and was already causing major problems for the village. Hardly a day went by without Adrian’s deputies receiving a complaint about the man. He grew strange plants in his garden, and conducted all sorts of experiments. Most of these were loud, garish, or just downright dangerous. Often, they ticked all of those boxes.
‘Is there a problem, officer?’ Neil asked, not for the first time in his life. Everything about him set Adrian’s teeth on edge. His innocent smile, his shabby jeans and sweater, and especially his hair. It was long, blonde and unkempt. The man had to be in his early forties, and he was flouncing about with a hairstyle that belonged on a teenager, if it belonged anywhere at all.
‘You can call me head judge Henley today, Morgan, and I think you know perfectly well that there’s a problem. What do you mean by bringing this disgrace here? Do you think it’s funny to make light of a contest which others have spent months preparing for?’
Professor Morgan looked taken aback. ‘I assure you officer… head judge Henley, sorry. I assure you that I’ve spent just as long preparing for the event as everyone else. Maybe my offering’s a bit unusual, but I thought I’d get points for being unique.’
‘It’s not unique, it’s a clear breach of rules!’ Adrian retorted. By now, the other judges had made their way to the broccoli marrow, or whatever the hell it was. He turned to them for support. ‘Should we even be wasting our time over here?’ There was a general shaking of heads and casting down of eyes, but professor Morgan was not to be deterred. ‘I read the rules before entering, there’s nothing here that breaches them.’
‘What do you call those bloody things on top of the damn thing then?’ Adrian pressed. ‘Article number six of the contest charter states, indeed clearly states, that entries must not be embellished with unnatural decorations. So I think that you’ll find that drilling holes in a vegetable, and then spray painting and inserting other vegetables is not only perverse and disgraceful, but it’s very obviously cheating.’
The professor held up his hands in protest. ‘No, no I did nothing of the sort! If you inspect closer, you’ll see that my vegetable actually grew that way. I’ve been having great success with my experiments cross breeding things. This is a totally new species, the only one in the world.’ Neil paused for effect, and then said ‘I call it… a broccarrow! It really has surpassed my wildest expectations. The marrow is actually the root of the plant, that part grows entirely underground. I’ll admit that I didn’t realise the broccoli bit would end up purple, but it’s got a certain amount of charm, wouldn’t you say?’
Adrian noticed with dismay that plenty of people seemed impressed by this madman. Even some of his fellow judges were nodding with approval, gazing with interest at the wretched thing. ‘Well, it’s unusual, but all the parts seem to have been cultivated well. And such a thing certainly hasn’t been managed before’ said Pauline Evans, another member of the panel. People in the crowd were chatting excitedly, and things were threatening to get out of hand. Adrian had to nip this whole business in the bud.
‘Tell me professor, did you have a permit to go playing god? There are laws to prevent this kind of thing. I’m not sure what laws, but that’s beside the point. How safe is it? How do you know it’s not poisonous? If we condone this thing in our contest, everyone’s going to want one. And I will not have it on my conscience when some child chokes to death on some purple bloody broccoli. I’m making an executive decision. You will remove your entry, and you will remove it now. It’s disqualified, and that’s the end of the matter.’
Neil looked to the other judges, but they were not daring to offer an opinion. His shoulders slumped. Reluctantly, he took his broccarrow and placed it into a large crate. Adrian got one last look at the awful purple broccoli stalks. Then, the professor put the lid onto the box and the nightmare was out of the judging panels’ lives. As Neil walked away, Pauline touched his arm. ‘Maybe next year, eh?’ she said with a smile. Adrian made a mental note to have her flower shop’s suspicious business records investigated.
‘Now that the damn broccoli debate is over, perhaps we can get back to what we’re actually here for’, he said. ‘Ah, lot number six, George Smith. Now here’s a man who knows how to grow produce properly!’
Neil made his way back to his small house. The day had not gone as planned. This was meant to have been the start of something big. His colleagues in London had not understood his genius. He thought perhaps a smaller community would be more welcoming, but it seemed that he was wrong. He sighed as he opened his green front door. He heard yapping as soon as he was across the threshold. A moment later, Mary, his adorable pug, came sauntering round the corner. This lifted his spirits immediately.
‘At least you love me for who I am’, he said, scratching the top of her head. ‘You know what Mary, I think I’ll enter you for Crufts next year. That should get me the recognition I deserve. We’ll forget all about brushing with broccoli, won’t we?’ He nodded his head. ‘Now, how about we tidy you up a bit? Those branches are getting a bit unruly. They’re threatening to get in the way of your wings!’
THE END
Adrian Henley, head of the judging panel and self proclaimed horticultural expert, cast an appraising eye over the offerings. His grey walrus moustache bristled with enthusiasm. A crowd always gathered to see what he made of things. The judging process was completely democratic. He and the six other members of the panel had an even say in the matter. The fact that his favourite entry had won every time in the contest’s twelve year history was mere coincidence. It had nothing to do with him being the head of the local police force. Rumours of Adrian holding delicate information over the heads of the other judges were just poor attempts by sour grapes to mar his reputation. Just because he did have access to such information proved nothing. He always picked the best entry anyway, so the argument was purely hypothetical.
Adrian smiled inwardly, whilst maintaining an air of outward professionalism. The crowd certainly was lively today. The contest marquee was full of people making their own inspections of the expertly grown vegetables. One entry in particular seemed to be drawing attention. He caught phrases such as ‘Never seen anything like it!’ and ‘I didn’t know you could do that with broccoli’. Adrian finished mentally destroying lot number five, a rather dismal pumpkin entered by Mrs Ashley. He headed to discover the source of the intrigue for himself. His career in the police force had made him hard to surprise. However, that assumption was about to be sorely tested.
Arriving at the entry in question, Adrian stopped short. His enthusiasm turned to confusion, and then to anger. This was clearly some sort of joke. It had to be. In front of him was a marrow. It was larger than average, but pretty unremarkable. At least it would have been, if not for the large heads of broccoli which sprouted from its top. Broccoli, which just happened to be a vibrant shade of purple. The ridiculous plants stuck up in a neat line, all along the marrow. If Adrian had been in a joking mood, he may have referred to it as the vegetable equivalent of a punk. He was not, however, in such a mood. The Best Vegetable competition was a prestigious and serious event. Stupid pranks had no place in it. He would get to the bottom of this, and the culprit would find themselves severely reprimanded.
‘Who is responsible for this… thing?’ he demanded. His heart sank, as someone stepped from the crowd and raised his hand. Professor Neil Morgan was a biologist, new to the area. He had moved to Ficti-on-Sea six months ago, and was already causing major problems for the village. Hardly a day went by without Adrian’s deputies receiving a complaint about the man. He grew strange plants in his garden, and conducted all sorts of experiments. Most of these were loud, garish, or just downright dangerous. Often, they ticked all of those boxes.
‘Is there a problem, officer?’ Neil asked, not for the first time in his life. Everything about him set Adrian’s teeth on edge. His innocent smile, his shabby jeans and sweater, and especially his hair. It was long, blonde and unkempt. The man had to be in his early forties, and he was flouncing about with a hairstyle that belonged on a teenager, if it belonged anywhere at all.
‘You can call me head judge Henley today, Morgan, and I think you know perfectly well that there’s a problem. What do you mean by bringing this disgrace here? Do you think it’s funny to make light of a contest which others have spent months preparing for?’
Professor Morgan looked taken aback. ‘I assure you officer… head judge Henley, sorry. I assure you that I’ve spent just as long preparing for the event as everyone else. Maybe my offering’s a bit unusual, but I thought I’d get points for being unique.’
‘It’s not unique, it’s a clear breach of rules!’ Adrian retorted. By now, the other judges had made their way to the broccoli marrow, or whatever the hell it was. He turned to them for support. ‘Should we even be wasting our time over here?’ There was a general shaking of heads and casting down of eyes, but professor Morgan was not to be deterred. ‘I read the rules before entering, there’s nothing here that breaches them.’
‘What do you call those bloody things on top of the damn thing then?’ Adrian pressed. ‘Article number six of the contest charter states, indeed clearly states, that entries must not be embellished with unnatural decorations. So I think that you’ll find that drilling holes in a vegetable, and then spray painting and inserting other vegetables is not only perverse and disgraceful, but it’s very obviously cheating.’
The professor held up his hands in protest. ‘No, no I did nothing of the sort! If you inspect closer, you’ll see that my vegetable actually grew that way. I’ve been having great success with my experiments cross breeding things. This is a totally new species, the only one in the world.’ Neil paused for effect, and then said ‘I call it… a broccarrow! It really has surpassed my wildest expectations. The marrow is actually the root of the plant, that part grows entirely underground. I’ll admit that I didn’t realise the broccoli bit would end up purple, but it’s got a certain amount of charm, wouldn’t you say?’
Adrian noticed with dismay that plenty of people seemed impressed by this madman. Even some of his fellow judges were nodding with approval, gazing with interest at the wretched thing. ‘Well, it’s unusual, but all the parts seem to have been cultivated well. And such a thing certainly hasn’t been managed before’ said Pauline Evans, another member of the panel. People in the crowd were chatting excitedly, and things were threatening to get out of hand. Adrian had to nip this whole business in the bud.
‘Tell me professor, did you have a permit to go playing god? There are laws to prevent this kind of thing. I’m not sure what laws, but that’s beside the point. How safe is it? How do you know it’s not poisonous? If we condone this thing in our contest, everyone’s going to want one. And I will not have it on my conscience when some child chokes to death on some purple bloody broccoli. I’m making an executive decision. You will remove your entry, and you will remove it now. It’s disqualified, and that’s the end of the matter.’
Neil looked to the other judges, but they were not daring to offer an opinion. His shoulders slumped. Reluctantly, he took his broccarrow and placed it into a large crate. Adrian got one last look at the awful purple broccoli stalks. Then, the professor put the lid onto the box and the nightmare was out of the judging panels’ lives. As Neil walked away, Pauline touched his arm. ‘Maybe next year, eh?’ she said with a smile. Adrian made a mental note to have her flower shop’s suspicious business records investigated.
‘Now that the damn broccoli debate is over, perhaps we can get back to what we’re actually here for’, he said. ‘Ah, lot number six, George Smith. Now here’s a man who knows how to grow produce properly!’
Neil made his way back to his small house. The day had not gone as planned. This was meant to have been the start of something big. His colleagues in London had not understood his genius. He thought perhaps a smaller community would be more welcoming, but it seemed that he was wrong. He sighed as he opened his green front door. He heard yapping as soon as he was across the threshold. A moment later, Mary, his adorable pug, came sauntering round the corner. This lifted his spirits immediately.
‘At least you love me for who I am’, he said, scratching the top of her head. ‘You know what Mary, I think I’ll enter you for Crufts next year. That should get me the recognition I deserve. We’ll forget all about brushing with broccoli, won’t we?’ He nodded his head. ‘Now, how about we tidy you up a bit? Those branches are getting a bit unruly. They’re threatening to get in the way of your wings!’
THE END
Featured Entry by writerGAKBUVWUMQ
Shouted conversation in the pub
concerning what we eat, and whether
Mr Broccoli did in fact produce or direct
the James Bond (or was it the Godfather?)
movies led to more research.
In Lincoln they're lining up the robots
to cut off the broccolis' heads. Apparently
it's long overdue; people pick them now
and get paid. I don't know about you,
but something I like to do in this
less personal modern world is, when
buying, say, frozen peas, to imagine the
designer working on the packet, drawing it,
quite proud of the end result and how nice and
green and appetising the peas are looking
before heading home for tea.
Now when I buy broccoli in the anodyne supermarket
will I have to expand my imagination still further
and think of a robot,
then of the person in the factory
making the robot,
taking real pride in its shiny eyes,
its super cutting arms,
and its joy at picking broccoli in a sunlit field?
concerning what we eat, and whether
Mr Broccoli did in fact produce or direct
the James Bond (or was it the Godfather?)
movies led to more research.
In Lincoln they're lining up the robots
to cut off the broccolis' heads. Apparently
it's long overdue; people pick them now
and get paid. I don't know about you,
but something I like to do in this
less personal modern world is, when
buying, say, frozen peas, to imagine the
designer working on the packet, drawing it,
quite proud of the end result and how nice and
green and appetising the peas are looking
before heading home for tea.
Now when I buy broccoli in the anodyne supermarket
will I have to expand my imagination still further
and think of a robot,
then of the person in the factory
making the robot,
taking real pride in its shiny eyes,
its super cutting arms,
and its joy at picking broccoli in a sunlit field?
Follow us on Twitter
Follow us on Instagram